Brown Justice

Brown Justice is the type of justice you just have to accept if you are brown in this country. As red neckers scramble to lap up Don’s latest musings that ‘Maaaaaaari get too much, and they aren’t even indigenous’, it’s often conveniently forgotten that institutionalized racism is alive and kicking in NZ, fronted by people who can’t possibly be racist because they have Maari friends.
Of course I make these comments pointing out the inconvenient truths of our system, knowing the usual screams from the right will post everything from “You left wing bastard” to “You race traitor” – in response, I will yawn.
Forget the fact that Maori get substandard service in hospitals or don’t even bother complaining about heavy sentences in prison because of a perceived bias, let’s look at three young woman, who if they had been white – would never have been charged with a crime they never committed, and then have had to battle for compensation.
Girls accept compensation for wrongful imprisonment
Three young girls jailed for a crime they did not commit have accepted an offer of compensation from the government. Tania Vini, Lucy Akatere and McCushla Fuataha have accepted compensation ranging between $162,000 and $176,000 each after a long battle for an increase on the initial amount offered.
Ms Vini will receive $176,621.36, Ms Akatere will receive $162,830.36, and Ms Fuataha will receive $165,330, Justice Minister Mark Burton said today.
The trio, then teenagers, were convicted in August 1999 for the aggravated robbery of a 16-year-old girl in Mt Roskill.
They served eight months in prison and were unable to finish school after being convicted of the gang attack and robbery of the teenage girl in Three Kings in August 1999.
They were acquitted in 2001, when the witness admitted she had lied, and the three were proven to have been nowhere near the scene.
>NZ Herald








19 Comments:
I blame this clown totally.
Trevor Franklin
Ex-Test Cricketer
As Police Detective,
Shonky investigation and perpetrator of injustice
He ignored the pleas of innocence of THREE girls over the lies of ONE girl.
He ignored all three girls alibi evidence.
He was only interested in nailing someone (it didn't matter who) for the crime and clear it off his books.
Has that lying little bitch payed the price?
Has that mongrel Franklin payed the price?
bentcops.org
Funny that they were all caught in a stolen car later on the same day of their acquittal...such angels...
Did they know it was stolen?
Savages - what are you saying? Are you accusing those three girls of being guilty of SOMETHING even if it wasn't what they were falsely accused and convicted of? What an intolerant and paranoid mindset you have.
"did they know it was stolen"...duh!!!!!
your comment re substandard service for Maoris in hospitals is a bit of a generalisation don't you think?
Let's not forget Arthur Allen Thomas ... white guy... got compensation ...
these girls were wrongly convicted ... got compensation ...
race shouldn't be the issue
Yeah right...check their background a little more...
Savages - how can I do that?
And, what difference does it make to the fact that they were unlawfully jailed for 7 months when they were in their early teens.
I don't think anyone is saying they were/are angels, but they were innocent of the crime they were accused of, and were treated badly. IMO, they deserve that compensation.
Why is this about race Bomber? I don't see it.
I have heard from other sources that they were actually guilty...that they have criminal records for other offences...that the witness was intimidated into retracting her statement...there is a lot more going on here than we are being let know.
My treatment at Waikato Hospital was first class. The doctors & especially the nurses were fantastic.
...
Deano - Institutionalized Racism: Tired cop, seeing brown face after brown face come in for this crime, for that crime, after a while all he does is look for brown faces to catch, and they all say they didn’t do it, so when he catches 3 who look likely, then looking likely is all you need anymore. If the girls had been white I just don’t believe they would have gone inside by accident. (btw - how is Japan? What's the word on their new PM - too hawkish for the Diet?)
Jack you make some very interesting points…
Trevor Franklin
Ex-Test Cricketer
As Police Detective,
Shonky investigation and perpetrator of injustice
He ignored the pleas of innocence of THREE girls over the lies of ONE girl.
He ignored all three girls alibi evidence.
Heres a bit more 'brown justice' for you...
http://subs.nzherald.co.nz/section/story.cfm?c_id=1&objectid=10405309
...
Lawyers claim three wrongly jailed women did not get higher compensation because of their age, race and social background.
Yesterday it was announced that Lucy Akatere, Tania Vini and McCushla Fuataha are to get payments ranging between $162,000 and $176,00.
Their lawyer Gary Gotlieb has said the compensation is not enough and he believed the girls had been "mucked around" because they were young and Polynesian.
Another lawyer, Peter Williams QC, who is also president of the Howard League for penal reform, said today there was "no doubt the colour of their skin" was a factor and if the women were people of high status their compensation would have been far greater.
Mr Williams told National Radio this morning: "I think there is a prejudice against people in what you may call the lower economic strata, I also think there is a prejudice against Maori people -- I think there is also a prejudice in this country against anyone who is a minority group."
The article forgot to add "Mr Williams, who also has never met a criminal he didn't like..."
...
wow - even after having their name cleared we still have all this suspision 'they did it' - and you wonder why Brown folk don't trust the justice system
William Sutch was cleared also, and most people still suspect he 'did it'...where's the difference.
As for OJ Simpson...racism obviously...
I feel sorry for those white men. Being treated like they get treated I mean.
AB
as a nurse the statement that maori get substandard service in hospital is disgusting. Maori and polynesian are the only groups in this country that have paid advocates visiting them daily to make sure they are happy and to make sure social situations are sorted, they get more input whilst in hospital than anyone. I agree there isnt equity in overall health for maori but the maori health strategy is bridging these gaps, not to mention maori nurses get paid more than the rest of us. So dont even get me started!!!! You obviously only see what you choose to and arent as educated as you try to make out you are.
Post a Comment
<< Home