- - - - - - - - - - - - -

Thursday, November 08, 2007

His Honour Judge A J Adeane: "You're a fucking egg!"

I missed this story when it came out on stuff but after hearing National Radio's distressed legal commentator talking about it the other day I had to look it up:
Judge takes plenty of prisoners
By the end of proceedings, Judge Tony Adeane had sentenced two young mothers to prison - one whose baby was just three days old - put a graffiti vandal in custody, ordered a man arrested for disrupting court, and put that man's mother into custody when she tried arguing.
Nearly all who came before him got a dressing-down and, by lunchtime, those still to enter the dock looked worried.
Some chattered nervously - and were promptly ordered by the judge to keep quiet.
The first indication of things to come was when Napier graffiti vandal Randall Gray, 19, was put into custody...


That's right the maximum possible penalty for shoplifting is 3 months and Judge Tony Adeane sentences a mother with a three day old child to 2 months in jail! This character is totally out of control. Read on:

A short time later, Brenda Keil - three days after giving birth to her third child - was sentenced to two months in prison for shoplifting and breaching community work.
Judge Adeane said Keil, 21, had "grotesquely thought she would not be sent to prison because she had young children".
He then reeled off a long list of prior offending. He said he regretted putting anyone with young children in jail, but Keil had left the court no option.
Her 19-year-old partner in crime, Destiny Gerbes, who has two children under three, was given four months in prison for the same offences.
"Ms Gerbes has a cavalier attitude to community responsibilities, including her children. You ... take the attitude that `I've got a couple of babies, no one's going to do anything to me' ... and that's where you've made your mistake," the judge said.
Gerbes' friend Cedric Ratima yelled out, "You're a f...ing egg" and was arrested.
He was held in custody till later in the day, when he was made to say sorry to the entire court.
The judge deemed his first attempt half-hearted, so ordered him to try again - this time to say he was very sorry.
Ratima's mother, Alicia Teau, then piped up, saying her son had already apologised.
Judge Adeane hauled her into the dock to explain herself. Unable to do so to his satisfaction, she joined her son in custody. Both later apologised sincerely and were freed.


Grotesque alright. National Radio's commentator said the total value of the stolen goods they both took was $203.11 and that the judge refused to adjourn the matter to a later date. The commentator said the Hawkes Bay judges operate a "get tough/be tough arrangement" quite at odds with normal practice elsewhere. He said many lawyers have left the area because they cannot deal with that sort of extraordinary regime.

This is exactly the reason why the new Sentencing Commission was established - to harmonise and even out sentencing between areas and offences. There is no formal method of disciplining judges in our system except actually dismissing them via parliament. This must change.

53 Comments:

At 8/11/07 1:00 pm, Anonymous Anonymous said...

So who is looking after these stupid cum-dumpster's babies when they're out graffiti'ing other peoples property and shop lifting?
Probably an "uncle" or the latest in a long line of partners or even no body at all - another Nia Glassie case just waiting to happen.
But don't worry Brenda and Randell - you can always blame "society" and have someone else pick up the pieces eh?

Good on you judge Adeanne - about fucking time.

 
At 8/11/07 1:00 pm, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Dear, oh dear, oh dear !!!
A judge that actually enforces the law !!! What will be next ? a decent society where no one breakes the law ? hevean forbid !

 
At 8/11/07 1:03 pm, Anonymous Anonymous said...

cum-dumpster's !!! Hehehehe, Brilliant !!!

 
At 8/11/07 2:17 pm, Anonymous Anonymous said...

This guy is my new hero. Good on him for not putting up with bullshit in his court.

 
At 8/11/07 3:15 pm, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Thats what judges are for, At last one doing his job. If we had them in Auckland Wanker Selwyn would still be inside.
One law for all I say jail means jail not to be served at home by some weak arsed law that allows you to get out for good behaviour. Life should mean Life no parole. Lets get tough on the barstards once and for all.

 
At 8/11/07 5:09 pm, Blogger Duncan Bayne said...

I can't believe you're whining about shoplifters being given jail time. Why should a thief be given leniency because she's just had a child?

 
At 8/11/07 5:38 pm, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Its one thing to steal because your to poor to buy the stuff; its another to be a judge that over steps ones boundary's with sentencing.

I will assume the Judges wife got caught, now he releaving his tension in the work place.

though it leaves grounds for an appeal, but 4 months = 12 weeks & 2 months is 3 weeks thats fuck all jail time, so maybe better to do the time.

Hated By Most

 
At 8/11/07 5:42 pm, Blogger Duncan Bayne said...

anonymous,

The thief (Brenda Keil) is a repeat offender already in trouble for breaching the terms of a previous sentence of community work. Don't try to portray her as some sort of starving innocent.

She has no respect for property, no respect for the law, and deserved the maximum three month sentence, not the two month sentence the judge handed down.

 
At 8/11/07 9:59 pm, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Fantastic thats the spirit good to see a judge with a decent pair of balls.
Brilliant stuff we need more of this in the justice system

 
At 8/11/07 11:05 pm, Blogger Duncan Bayne said...

So just to get this one right if some breaks the law its "you fuck crim, homey or whatever... But when a Judge does it or a cop their fuck heroes?

If I understand you correctly, you're complaining that the judge broke the law?

If that's the case, would you mind telling us what laws you think the judge broke?

 
At 9/11/07 6:43 am, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Judge Adeane is my new hero. Now, if we can just get the rest of the ridiculous twats on the bench to follow his example NZ can turn the corner and start getting back to being a nice place to live again.

 
At 9/11/07 7:25 am, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Duncan Bayne said...
If I understand you correctly, you're complaining that the judge broke the law?
If that's the case, would you mind telling us what laws you think the judge broke?


maximum sentence for theft less (500)is 3 months prison not 4; it is not open to the Judge to give a sentence over and above what the LAW states. Can you use the same speech Duncan with the police? doubtful. So it makes it ok for them and not ok for everyone else; as for the history speech you raised Duncan, isn't it something she already paid for?

Hated By Most

 
At 9/11/07 7:37 am, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Two wrongs make a right hated?

A policeman committed a crime therefore we can't trust any of them, nor the judiciary?

Such simpistic (non)thinking.

When a police officer commits a crime, that makes them a criminal, just like our young mums doing time inside.

 
At 9/11/07 7:38 am, Blogger Mana said...

I believe that guy showed some balls when he called the Judge a "fucking egg" and rightfully so he is a "fucking egg" the sentence for contempt of court is punishable only by fine, I'd be fucked if I would apologised to the "fucking egg" for send people to prison for such a minor offence.

But I am glad you all like the idea, now don't complain about were your taxes headed, $360 per day for one inmate lol thanks Duncan & co

 
At 9/11/07 7:53 am, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Anonymous said...
Two wrongs make a right hated?

why are you asking me anon, its you policemen that break the law and you all feel ok with it, its your Judges that over step the boundaries set by written law and again your ok with it.

so why ask me?


A policeman committed a crime therefore we can't trust any of them, nor the judiciary?
You trust them anon, no one saying you can't, just hope they don't rape your daughter and then say she want it or beat your son and say he resisted arrest...but I guess your right huh... our judiciary is so tip top, lets ask Bains what he think about our justice system? You know anon you and others portrait a form of Self Righteousness, does it justify a lot when the police & judiciary break the law they are to uphold, now if they do it often enough, with the anons gleeful smile, whats to say they won't do it to you. if we all continue to let it happen.

Hated by Most

 
At 9/11/07 9:13 am, Blogger Barnsley Bill said...

Tim, I suspect you are dog whistling with this post.
Not too many would agree with your sentiment towards these people, theft is theft.
I would be more upset if they had escaped a custodial sentence because they have children.

 
At 9/11/07 9:17 am, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Anonymous said...
Piss off hated and stop trying to confuse the issue, No one here has said that cops or judges shouldn't be punished to the full extent of the law if they commit a crime. We are all just happy that their is finally a judge who is prepared to actually hand down a real sentance for once rather than just let them off with some bullshit pd (that probably won't be done) or a fine (that probably won't be paid).
Have a shit anon, no one here even made mention that the Judge handed down a sentence outside the max for the crime, yet on your breath, "No one here has said that cops or judges shouldn't be punished to the full extent of the law if they commit a crime"
YEAH RIGHT.....


Hated By Most

 
At 9/11/07 10:08 am, Anonymous Anonymous said...

"no one here even made mention that the Judge handed down a sentence outside the max for the crime

Thats because because the judge DIDN'T hand down a sentence outside the max - can you not read?

"No one here has said that cops or judges shouldn't be punished to the full extent of the law if they commit a crime"
YEAH RIGHT.....

Well then Hated, why don't you show us all where anybody in this thread has claimed that the police or judges shouldn't be prosecuted for crimes? Oh that's right - you can't because no one here has said that, stop trying to project on to us your own stupid belief that people who want to be harder on crims think it's ok for cops or the judiciary to be crooked.

 
At 9/11/07 10:09 am, Anonymous Anonymous said...

It's obvious from the recidivist nature of the offending that only a short sharp shock is going to keep them from a longer prison stretch in the future.

It doesn't take much to impress Mana does it? Just abuse some figure of authority and he thinks your the man.

 
At 9/11/07 10:25 am, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Anonymous said...
Well then Hated, why don't you show us all where anybody in this thread has claimed that the police or judges shouldn't be prosecuted for crimes? Oh that's right - you can't because no one here has said that, stop trying to project on to us your own stupid belief that people who want to be harder on crims think it's ok for cops or the judiciary to be crooked

Anon maybe you can show us were someone else pointed out that the Judge over stepped his boundary in sentencing outside the written law, or tell us is it lawful for a Judge to do that?

Hated by Most

 
At 9/11/07 10:25 am, Blogger Mana said...

Anonymous said...

It's obvious from the recidivist nature of the offending that only a short sharp shock is going to keep them from a longer prison stretch in the future.

It doesn't take much to impress Mana does it? Just abuse some figure of authority and he thinks your the man.


Please explain anon, as I have only posted once here, it had nothing to do with sentencing, only about the Judge being called a "fucking egg" which in my opinion he is, thats my opinion

 
At 9/11/07 10:27 am, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Is it against the law to be a fart gobbler? If so then most of the Ayn Rand reading, "in love with the musk of their own anal vapours" right wing cockblowers here should be wearing orange boiler suits inbetween naked "quality time" with the warden's German Shepherd and fire hose.

 
At 9/11/07 10:51 am, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Anon maybe you can show us were someone else pointed out that the Judge over stepped his boundary in sentencing outside the written law, or tell us is it lawful for a Judge to do that?

What exactly is your point Hated? The judge DIDN'T sentence anyone in a way that over stepped the boundaries of written law, whether that would be lawful or not is COMPLETELY irrelevant because it DID NOT happen. Apparently these simple facts are beyond your comprehension.

Some stupid shit bag got caught committing illegal acts and has been lawfully sentenced to time in prison for it. Why is this a problem? Good on you Judge Adeanne.

 
At 9/11/07 11:20 am, Anonymous Anonymous said...

"Some stupid shit bag got caught committing illegal acts and has been lawfully sentenced to time in prison for it. Why is this a problem?"

It's a problem for Hated cos he's a lowlife crim.

 
At 9/11/07 1:38 pm, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Those kids need to be put up for adoption so they have a chance at a real life.

Leave them with those useless slags and we all know what their future is.

By the way the amout is irrelevant - I have some stuff stolen 'only' $100, might be 'only' to people like you but that was a fortune to me at the time.

Just because $200 ++ is nothing to you don't minimise the impact that can have on other people.

Why does this rif-raf keep banging out kids they don't care about and can't provide for - it is the benifit money or are they just to stupid to work out how to stop it.

Forget about that useless bitch it's to late for here, think about those children and give them a future.

 
At 9/11/07 2:04 pm, Anonymous Anonymous said...

They should be sterilised as part of their sentence. These people are nothing but a drain on society which must be stopped.

The only fucking egg here is you mana. Seems like your thinking from the perspective of a crim not a law abiding citizen.

 
At 9/11/07 3:02 pm, Anonymous Anonymous said...

You are definately a candidate for sterilisation. It's obvious to anyone with an ounce of intellect that the Nazis hated homosexuals. The fact that you can't even accurately insult someone justifies making sure that mongoloid retards such as yourself never ever have the opportunity to procreate.

 
At 9/11/07 4:06 pm, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Homophobia is alive and well on the left, what a surprise.

 
At 9/11/07 7:47 pm, Blogger Mana said...

It kinda creeps me out to think that if all you anons are separate people, just how many narrow minded, so called kiwis their is in Aotearoa.

 
At 9/11/07 8:30 pm, Anonymous Anonymous said...

"so called kiwis their is in Aotearoa."

There are a lot of so-called maori out there with more white than maori blood who just use their race to get a handout.

Last time I looked I was living in New Zealand.

 
At 9/11/07 10:36 pm, Blogger Mana said...

Anonymous said...
"so called kiwis their is in Aotearoa."

There are a lot of so-called maori out there with more white than maori blood who just use their race to get a handout.
What the Fuck, now you want to tell me as to what degree or amount of blood I have is Maori, what a dick, come on then give me the names of my Tupuna and point out where your fucking white blood comes into it. Now what fucking hand out is it that we get, not this $1000 grant everyone goes on about that no one can name

Last time I looked I was living in New Zealand.
your a descendant of an immigrant lol makes you and over stayer lol
(sorry but always wanted to say that; But it's true; lol)

 
At 10/11/07 12:17 am, Anonymous Anonymous said...

It appears that you're trying to overcompensate by trying to emphasis your maoriness over the whatever else you're got mixed up there. Just like that Jamie Lockett clown running around pretending to be maori and wanting to kill the pakeha when it was clear to any observer that he had a minimal amount of maori blood in him. Just trying to makeup for what he didn't have in the first place.

And as for overstayers, it really depends on which law you're following and last time I looked it was ours that you were following. Thats the only truth worth recognising. You can keep you little overstayer remarks as a consolation prize if it makes you feel any better.

 
At 10/11/07 1:42 am, Blogger Mana said...

This comment has been removed by the author.

 
At 10/11/07 9:17 am, Blogger Mana said...

My bloodline, it not me that made the assumption anon, but the only thing you lack is proof; so do you have any? no not fucken likely, so it is assume assume and assume huh, but I'll give you a chance to prove your little white hope. By the way you have not mentioned what these handout are? But anon your grasping at straws; no where have I ever fucking said I support Tame Iti & co, but Jamie Lockett is your problem not mine, I don't care what he wants to do, whether he is truthful about his intentions, fuck knows, he said "that Pakeha are going to die" lol so why should I be concerned about that. There are some Pakeha I think don't deserve to die and then theirs Pakeha like you that should die, but painfully, oh no look I must be a terrorist; lol, look how easy that was....

And as for over stayers, it really depends on which law you're following
Desperate anon... come on now I am suppose to a white blood Maori, to which you can't prove, but I can prove your a descendant of a immigrant, its kinda funny when you watch people like yourself go on about other immigrants yet your a product of one, the apple don't fall that far from the tree anon.

But I made mention many many times that I challenge this countries laws, it's constitutional status , so how on earth do I follow your law...more assumptions anon shit your good at that. But the Over stayer remark isn't a prize, it's the truth anon, because no matter how hard you try, you can't change it; thats what you are.

 
At 10/11/07 11:42 am, Anonymous Anonymous said...

How do you define 'challenge'? would that be spouting your maori independence shite on anonymous forum or flying your little flag above your house in south auckland. Challenging stuff indeed.

As far as your strange obsession with bloodlines goes it suppose that is the real consolation for you that you are who you are because of who your ancestors were not because of anything you've actually done yourself. Seems more of a weakness than a strength.

You still don't get it mana. The pakeha define the truth because we are in control which is the only truth that matters.

 
At 10/11/07 12:21 pm, Blogger Mana said...

This comment has been removed by the author.

 
At 10/11/07 12:28 pm, Blogger Mana said...

Anonymous said...
How do you define 'challenge'? would that be spouting your maori independence shite on anonymous forum or flying your little flag above your house in south auckland. Challenging stuff indeed.
What wrong anon are Maori Activist getting to you? I always said anon I don't have nothing against Pakeha people, neither do I believe like other Maori activist; that just want pakeha like yourself to just fuck off, no I believe in sharing this countries resources, I challenge the govt through its courts as fair as the Privy council to which I have been once, normally the Court of Appeal slap this govts ass and compensates us for the govt unlawful acts and breaches.

As far as your strange obsession with bloodlines goes it suppose that is the real consolation for you that you are who you are because of who your ancestors were not because of anything you've actually done yourself. Seems more of a weakness than a strength.
First you come with the majority white blood Maori theory anon and now its because of my ancestor and not me, dude I don't think you have the faintest idea what your on about, My ancestors stood in the present of your fore father King and Queen, while yours probably crawled of the slums of Ol England banged of a convict ship bound for Australia. I was raised on Waitangi Marae, being Maori and fighting for our rights is all I ever saw, please don't try and assume you know me or my tupuna, you would be more justified talking about "Thomas the tank engine"
You still don't get it mana. The pakeha define the truth because we are in control which is the only truth that matters.
Truth is what I said to you about your ancestors and you being a product of an immigrant; If you call not being able to lay charges on the 17 accused "CONTROL" I think you need to leave the weed alone, its fucking you up, because somewhere your so called "CONTROL" went to SHIT.

 
At 10/11/07 12:56 pm, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Yeah right, and you're probably related to maori royalty or something too.

Strange how your posts sound like Hated by Most with the same spelling mistakes, formatting and phrases.

You remember Hated don't you, that blowhard who tried to convince us he was a member of the hell's angels, owned 3 houses and lived in kohi and claimed to bribe police.

Sounds like the same tryhard making the same kinds of grandiose claims but this time about how his ancestors stood in front of a king as a way of trying to impress us.

Seems like you really do live in south Auckland then.

Better luck next time Turd.

 
At 10/11/07 3:02 pm, Blogger Mana said...

Oh far out anon, this ones been tried already if you can beat them insult them huh.

I was accused of being hated before, but to clear that up if you skip back a couple of posts you will see we both posted at the same time,

I wish I could be in 2 places at once anon but even for me that a little hard. but I feel for you.... oh know it was wind .. normally I would read and correct my posts anon, but seeing theres so fucking many of you that reply I let it slip...

but think what you want anon, it is something your good at.

 
At 10/11/07 6:41 pm, Blogger Mana said...

I copy and pasted some of hated's saying, G sorry anon should I check with you first?

Like I said before you believe what you want, but your wrong, weren't the same.

 
At 10/11/07 7:56 pm, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Keep on spinning cocksmack.

Do you really think we're impressed with your lies mana/turd? They just make you sound like a little boy trying to impress the grownups.

 
At 10/11/07 9:08 pm, Anonymous Anonymous said...

For someone attending a hell's angel bbq you certainly have the time to reply to an anon poster. Or is it because you're some fronting wannabe sitting in south akl trying to be the man.

what a sad little cocksmack you are
mana/turd.

 
At 10/11/07 10:06 pm, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Oh what wrong anon still could answer the question...bit hard is it, dick head; by the way that south Auckland routine been tried before don't you fucking remember, we can clear this up easy as, if you grew some nuts and come down here.

BBQ ended at 7.30 dick but of course we are suppose to be like haow you fucken portrait us all to be; right Anon? yes of course, though some of the boy are still drinking, I don't drink that much anymore, but I was hopeful that super Anon was coming over, to put forth his views. but as usual just talk shit and assumptions;

What get you down Anne, 17 get of the terrorist charges lol, you pop the wife and are wait ever so patiently for repairs; I think it them Maori's that got you down, lol go burn a cross outside and feel better. Better fucking luck next time... you poor bitch

Hated By Most

 
At 10/11/07 10:37 pm, Anonymous Anonymous said...

And you want us to believe you because you posted it on a forum?

Whatever cockboy

Nice attempt at trying to explain away similarities in posts because you copy and pasted them. But then again since you're using the same pc it's pretty plausible.

How does it feel to look in the mirror mana/turd and see a sad loser who's sense of self worth is based on trying to impress anon posters.

 
At 10/11/07 11:05 pm, Anonymous Anonymous said...

How about you post the landline telephone number of the HAMC clubrooms up here. I've got some contacts in the teleco industry who can verify if you're telling the truth very easily.

If not the crawl back under the rock from whence you came.

 
At 11/11/07 9:57 am, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Once again turd fails to provide the relevant info.

The fact that you post at the same time is proof you're the same person moron.

hells angel indeed. what a joke

 
At 11/11/07 1:05 pm, Anonymous Anonymous said...

I'm still waiting cocksmack.

All I'm hearing are excuses and empty threats.

You can't even follow through on a simple ph number.

I guess we know the truth now.

 
At 11/11/07 6:33 pm, Anonymous Anonymous said...

to the righteous, arrogant, dungpunching fascists out there. it's okay to use terms that could be construed as homophobic in our attacks upon you. because, next to anything non-white or non-male, gays are equally as likely to make you break out into a neck rash.
so go back to plundering your dirtchutes with whatever broomstick, table leg or police baton you have handy you hateful fascist nazi manginas.
LOL!!!

 
At 11/11/07 8:45 pm, Anonymous Anonymous said...

LOL he said mangina.

 
At 12/11/07 10:44 am, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Looks like you're wasting our time Turd. All it takes to prove who you are is 7 numbers and you can't even ante up with that so we should anyone believe you.

Don't forget you're the one making the big claims here not anyone else.

Face it Turd, you're nothing but wannabe and a joke trying to impress anon poster.

 
At 12/11/07 11:21 am, Blogger Tim Selwyn said...

Tim kick these 2 out
MARKY MARK


Sometimes it's instructive, but usually it degenerates quickly into the personal and nasty, so I take your point. I was busy the last few days so it ran loose.

So to those affected: please debate ideas and information and not so much each other.

 
At 13/11/07 8:24 pm, Blogger Jends Fisher said...

This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

 
At 15/11/07 1:57 pm, Blogger Jends Fisher said...

This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home